I return to a familiar theme for this blog, prompted by a couple of reviews of my DCI John Blizzard books on Amazon, which tapped into one of the hotly-debated issues as ‘modern’ readers undergo changes in the kind of writing that they appreciate.

Both reviews related to the question ‘how much is enough?’  One review did not like the amount of description of characters that I use and the other suggested that I use too much back story.

Go back a few decades and this was not really an issue for publishers or readers. Readers in those days expected novels to contain plenty of description but, over the years, that has changed, driven in part by the advent of the Twitter (now x) age where stories are communicated in just a few words. 

Also changing readers’ preferences has been the arrival of the world of Kindle, in which so many more books are available than ever before that the market place has become highly competitive. With many books only costing 99p (not to mention anthologies at the same price) readers are much more likely to ditch a book if they do not like what they see in the first couple of pages, because the book did not cost them much.

As a result, authors have found that the amount of description and back story they use have become issues which are increasingly occupying the thoughts of publishers and their editors, who know that a significant proportion of the new generation of readers are keen for the authors to ‘get on with it’ and not write anything which slows down the narrative, or else they’ll go elsewhere.

All of which brings us back to the question ‘how much is enough?’ When it comes to description, I agree that the reader does not need half a page describing a character and that most of their characteristics will emerge from what they say and do as the story unfolds but I do think that there should be some clues for the reader right at the outset.

As an author, I tend to limit the physical description of significant characters when they make their first appearance. I will summarise a small number of characteristics in a line or two, which tends to include hair colour, body shape (are they tall or short, lean or paunchy?) clothing and demeanour, adding up to a snapshot of what they are like. I feel that gives the reader something with which to build an initial picture of the character. I think the reader benefits from that as long as it is not overdone.

And so to back story. As authors, we need to be careful with not overdoing back story but some of it is needed because a character’s history is an important part of who they are.

However, the author has to be aware that every instance of us delving into their past can have the effect of slowing the novel’s forward momentum. One of the most common mistakes I note when I’m called upon to offer comments on inexperienced writers’ manuscripts is that they have spent too much time establishing the background to the story early on in the book, which slows the pace. Lose pace and you lose your reader because often they will not wait for the story to get into gear. Besides, there’s actually very little that readers need to know about our characters’ history from the outset that they won’t learn as the story unfolds. An author can, by all means, refer to the past and slot in short passages of flashback if they think it will help the reader build a better picture of the character but, again, it’s a case of not overdoing it.

Views: 18

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of John Dean Crime Novelist to add comments!

Join John Dean Crime Novelist

Latest Activity

Filling Machine updated their profile
23 hours ago
Packaging Machinery updated their profile
yesterday
John Dean posted a blog post

Happy Christmas and a peaceful New Year to you all

Festive greetings from the team at Kirkcudbright Book Week Society. We hope you have a happy and peaceful festive season.See More
Dec 20
John Dean shared their blog post on Facebook
Dec 13
John Dean shared their blog post on Facebook
Dec 13
John Dean posted a blog post

Written in a flash

 I am part of the team that organises an annual short story competition for young writers in Dumfries and Galloway, as part of the run-up to Kirkcudbright book week 2025 in March. The competition is run by the event organisers Kirkcudbright Book Week Society and Kirkcudbright Library. Myself and Lesley Garbutt from the Library are the judges and this year we have asked…See More
Dec 13
John Dean posted a blog post

Festival announces top quality crime fiction line-up

One of the strongest features of Kirkcudbright Book Week right from its early days has been the popularity of crime fiction - and the 2025 event is set to continue the tradition.The programme to run in the South West Scotland town between March 3-9 includes appearances by several best-selling crime fiction authors as well as those starting out  on their writing…See More
Dec 10
John Dean shared their blog post on Facebook
Dec 8
John Dean shared their blog post on Facebook
Dec 7
John Dean posted a blog post

How to keep a long-running series fresh

Writing a long-running series of novels, as can so often be the case for crime fiction authors, brings its own set of challenges, not least how do you keep the writing fresh for reader and writer alike?As I start the latest DCI  Jack Harris novel for my publisher The Book Folks, the twelfth in the series where the action is divided between the North Pennines and southern…See More
Dec 7
John Dean shared their blog post on Facebook
Nov 20
John Dean shared their blog post on Facebook
Nov 20
John Dean posted a blog post

An exciting time

Having just completed my latest DCI Blizzard crime novel for my publisher The Book Folks, this is both a nervous time and an exciting time. Nervous because, however experienced you are (and this is Book 25), it’s always a tense time as you wait for feedback from your publisher. You are never too old to learn!Exciting because your thoughts turn to the next book, which…See More
Nov 20
John Dean left a comment for Ray Ogden
"Hi Ray Welcome to my site All the best John"
Nov 18
Ray Ogden is now a member of John Dean Crime Novelist
Nov 18
Ronald Morris is now a member of John Dean Crime Novelist
Nov 6

Videos

Members

© 2024   Created by John Dean.   Powered by

Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service